What Are the Worst Semi Truck Engines Out There?

Technical Issues
1

When it comes to semi trucks, the engine is arguably the heart of the machine. Unfortunately, not all engines are created equal, and some have developed quite the reputation for being problematic. If you’re in the market for a semi truck or just curious about which engines to steer clear of, this discussion is for you.

Common Issues with Poor-Performing Engines

  1. Reliability Problems: Many drivers have reported reliability issues with certain engines, leading to unexpected breakdowns. These instances can not only be inconvenient but can also lead to costly repairs that eat into your profits.
  2. Fuel Efficiency: Some engines may provide less power while consuming more fuel, impacting your overall operating costs. An inefficient engine can stack up significant expenses over time.
  3. Frequent Maintenance: If your engine requires frequent repairs or specialized maintenance that escalates costs, it may be best to avoid that model.
  4. Resale Value: Certain engines, known for poor performance, often have lower resale values. Investing in an engine with a bad reputation means you may lose money down the line when you try to sell it.

Engines to Avoid

Here’s a quick list of engines that have been criticized by the trucking community:

  • International MaxxForce Engines: Known for their reliability issues and frequent recalls, many drivers recommend steering clear of these.
  • Detroit Diesel Series 60: While some swear by them, others have noted performance inconsistencies that lead to more repairs.
  • Caterpillar C13/C15: Despite being popular, they come with complaints about fuel system issues and higher maintenance costs.

Experiences and Recommendations

A few drivers have shared their experiences, indicating that they faced various challenges with the engines mentioned above, making them question their purchases. Others have chimed in, advocating for engines they found more reliable.

Personal Stories

  • User123 mentioned that their International truck spent more time in the shop than on the road, while another user, TruckerMike, shared that a Peterbilt with a Cummins engine has been nothing but dependable for him.

Conclusion

In summary, while some semi truck engines have garnered negative reputations, it’s critical to do thorough research before making your purchase. Listening to the experiences of others in the trucking community can provide valuable insights and help you avoid costly mistakes. Let’s discuss your experiences! What engines have you found to be the worst, and why?

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

8 Likes
2

I’ve heard that the Detroit Diesel Series 60 has a lot of common issues, particularly with injectors. It’s frustrating when a small part causes so much downtime.

3

Absolutely! I’ve also come across drivers who say the Volvo D13 can have frequent regeneration issues that lead to breakdowns. It’s a headache when you rely on your truck for income.

4

The Cummins ISX engine is notorious for having turbocharger and EGR problems that seem to plague many fleets. Anyone else dealing with this?

5

For sure! The parts are pricey too, which adds to the operational costs. It’s like a double whammy for trucking companies.

3 Likes
6

What about the PACCAR MX-13? I’ve seen posts about issues with their pistons failing. Seems like that could be a huge deal.

7

Great point! A failed piston can sideline a truck for weeks. It’s risky business when you depend on these engines daily.

7 Likes
8

I’ve always been curious why some engines are more prone to overheating than others. Does anyone have insights on that?

1 Like
9

A lot of it comes down to design and maintenance. Engine cooling systems that are poorly designed tend to have these issues. Anyone agree?

6 Likes
10

Honestly, I’ve experienced some breakdowns due to water pump failures on older engines. It’s part of the game, unfortunately.

11

Water pumps are often overlooked in preventive maintenance! It’s those little things that can really throw off your schedule.

12

It seems the more complex the engine, the more potential points of failure there are. Why invest in brands that overcomplicate systems?

3 Likes
13

Exactly! Simplicity often equals reliability. It’s why I’m skeptical about newer engine models. Are they really worth it?

14

I once joked that my truck was ‘affectionately’ known as a ‘money pit’ because of all the repairs. But seriously, the upkeep can become overwhelming!

1 Like
15

Haha, tell me about it! My engine is like a bad relationship: constantly needing attention and never enough!

7 Likes
16

We shouldn’t forget about maintenance practices. Sometimes it’s bad habits that lead to engine failures more than the engine design itself.

17

That is a crucial point! Regular checks can save a lot of heartache down the line.

18

I’ve heard a lot of bad things about the Volvo D12 engine. The maintenance costs can be astronomical, and finding parts is often a nightmare.

19

I agree! The D12 can be a real money pit. Plus, the availability of skilled technicians who know how to handle them is limited in many areas.

3 Likes
20

Anyone had issues with the Caterpillar C15? It’s known for fuel system problems, and fixing it can be pricey.