Super Clean vs Simple Green for Car Detailing: Which One Wins?

Detailing & Car Care
1

Introduction

When it comes to keeping our vehicles looking pristine, choosing the right cleaning product can make all the difference. Recently, I’ve been hearing a lot of buzz about two popular cleaners: Super Clean and Simple Green. Both brands claim to deliver exceptional results, but how do they stack up against each other, especially for automotive applications? Let’s dive into their effectiveness, safety, and overall suitability for car detailing!

Comparison Overview

Effectiveness

  • Super Clean: Known for its heavy-duty cleaning power, Super Clean is especially effective on tough grease and grime. It’s often recommended for use on engine bays, wheels, and other heavily soiled areas.
  • Simple Green: This product boasts versatility and is often favored for its non-toxic formula, making it safe for both indoor and outdoor use. In automotive applications, it performs well on carpets, upholstery, and painted surfaces.

Safety

  • Super Clean: While it’s powerful, some users have reported issues with the potential damage to certain materials if not monitored carefully. Caution is advised when using it on delicate surfaces.
  • Simple Green: Generally recognized as a safer option, it’s biodegradable and non-toxic, making it an excellent choice for cleaning the interiors of vehicles without risk to passengers or pets.

Material Compatibility

  • Super Clean: Excellent for tough jobs but can cause damage to rubber and certain plastics if left too long. It’s best practiced in a well-ventilated area and requires thorough rinsing.
  • Simple Green: Its gentle formula makes it compatible with a variety of surfaces, including plastics, metals, and fabrics, without the risk of damaging your car’s interior or exterior.

User Experiences

Many users with extensive automotive detailing experience have shared their thoughts:

  • Those who opt for Super Clean often rave about its unbelievable strength when tackling tough jobs, especially on tires and wheels.
  • In contrast, users of Simple Green appreciate its ease of use and the fact that they can clean a variety of surfaces without worrying about causing damage.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Choosing between Super Clean and Simple Green really boils down to what you need.

  • If you’re looking for a heavy-duty cleaner for tough grease, Super Clean might be your go-to.
  • If you prefer a more versatile and safer option for general cleaning, then Simple Green would be the better choice.

What are your experiences with these products? Have you found other cleaners that you think might be better? Let’s share our thoughts to find the ultimate cleaning solution for our vehicles!

Final Thoughts

It’s essential to consider what you’re cleaning and the materials involved. If you have any tips or experiences with either product that could help others, feel free to drop your comments below!

7 Likes
2

I’ve used both Super Clean and Simple Green, and I must say Super Clean really excels at cutting through tough grime, especially in the garage. It’s a powerhouse for heavy-duty stains.

3

I’ve found Simple Green to be fantastic for everyday cleaning, especially in kitchens. It’s environmentally friendly, so it doesn’t just clean but also cares for the space.

4

It seems like Super Clean might be better for those tougher, grease-heavy stains in garages. But how does it hold up on lighter stains, or say, for car detailing purposes?

5

That’s a great question! From my experience, Super Clean is unbeatable on heavy-duty dirt, but for light cleaning, Simple Green is more than adequate.

6

I think it really depends on the environment. For outdoor spaces and tough stains, Super Clean is definitely my go-to. Does anyone have tips on diluting it for better results?

7

I dilute it a bit in a spray bottle, and it works wonders! But make sure to test it on a small area first.

8

I love both brands, but for outdoor use, Super Clean has better penetration and adhesion to surfaces. Simple Green is my favorite for regular maintenance indoors.

9

Totally agree! I noticed that Super Clean works more effectively on oil stains left on driveways. However, how does it compare when safety for paint is concerned?

10

In terms of safety, I’ve used Super Clean on paint with caution and it has worked fine. Just be quick and follow up with rinsing! Simple Green is easy-going and safe for all surfaces.

11

Sounds like a win-win! Each product has its strengths, so it’s great to know when to use which.

3 Likes
12

Can’t we all just agree that they each have their place? It’s like choosing between apples and oranges! Just don’t mix them; that’s a recipe for cleaning chaos!

7 Likes
13

I’ve used both Super Clean and Simple Green for detailing, and I feel more comfortable with Simple Green. It’s non-toxic and has a better eco-friendly profile. My kids often help, so safety is a big priority for us!

14

Interesting! I had no idea Simple Green was safer. What about Super Clean’s biodegradability? Has anyone looked into that?

4 Likes
15

Both products are relatively safe but remember that Super Clean can be harsher on surfaces. If you’re detailing regularly, I suggest going for something more user-friendly and eco-conscious like Simple Green.

16

I’ve used Super Clean before, and while it gets the job done, I found it to be a little too intense. Simple Green seems like the better choice for regular use.

17

Exactly! Plus, I appreciate Simple Green’s commitment to being biodegradable—definitely a win for the environment!

18

It’s so true! Safety for our families while washing cars is so important. I stick to Simple Green for almost all cleaning tasks—less worry overall.

19

Great point! Having something non-toxic is essential when kids are involved. I wish more products prioritized this.

5 Likes
20

I wonder about the long-term effects of both products on the environment. Has any research been done on the harmful effects of Super Clean specifically?