Best All-Season Tires for Harsh Minnesota Winters?

Tires & Wheels
1

I’m on the hunt for some all-season tires that can handle the unpredictable weather here in Minnesota. Any recommendations?

What I’m Looking For:

  • Durability: I need tires that can withstand icy roads and heavy snowfall.
  • Performance: Handling and traction are key, especially during harsh winter conditions.
  • Noise: The quieter, the better!

What I’ve Considered So Far:

  1. Michelin CrossClimate 2
    • Noted for good winter performance and comfort.
  2. Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady
    • Designed for all weather conditions but I’ve seen mixed reviews.
  3. Continental TrueContact Tour
    • Good all-around tire but unsure about deep snow.

Questions I Have:

  • What has been your personal experience with these tires in deep snow?
  • Are there any brands or models that I should steer clear of?
  • Has anyone tried a mix of winter and all-season tires?

Feel free to share any recommendations or tips! Your insights could really help me make a better choice. Thanks!

2

I’ve been using the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tires, and they performed surprisingly well in the snow. The traction levels are pretty solid, and I’ve noticed a reduction in braking distance on icy roads.

3

I’ve had mixed experiences with those. The tread seems to wear out faster than other all-season tires. Has anyone tried the Michelin CrossClimate2? I’ve heard great things about its winter performance!

4

The Michelin CrossClimate2 is excellent! I never felt unsafe driving in snow or on ice. It provides exceptional traction, though they are a bit pricey upfront. Worth it for security on the road, though!

5

Yes! They really deliver in harsh winter conditions. I also found that their braking distance was much better than other all-season options I’ve had.

6

I second the CrossClimate2 as well! I’ve been using them for two winters, and they’re fantastic on snow and slush. But I do wonder if they really hold up in extreme cold for long-term use.

7

I’ve switched to Bridgestone WeatherPeak tires, but honestly, they’re not as good as expected. While they’re decent in rain, ice has been a challenge; I find myself slipping a bit too often.

1 Like
8

That’s frustrating! I’ve heard the same about them from others. What about the Continental TrueContact? Anyone had experience with those?

9

The Continental TrueContact is pretty decent, but like others, it struggles on heavy snow. For Minnesota winters, you might want a dedicated winter tire instead. Just saying!

3 Likes
10

Honestly, I think all-season tires can be a bit overrated for harsh winters. I used to use them but switched to winter tires. The difference in traction is night and day!

11

True, but not everyone wants to switch tires every season! Can’t we find a happy medium with all-season options?

12

A happy medium would definitely be ideal! But if you’re in Minnesota, I’d recommend prioritizing performance over versatility in really harsh winter scenarios.

13

I can recommend the Michelin CrossClimate2. It’s known for great tread longevity and performs well in snow and rain, making it perfect for Minnesota winters.

14

I’ve heard great things about the CrossClimate2! What about its wear resistance compared to other all-season tires?

15

Longevity can be a mixed bag with all-season tires in harsh conditions. Make sure to check the treadwear warranty while shopping.

1 Like
16

I’ve had the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady on my SUV. It has decent longevity, but keep an eye on tread depth as it can wear quicker in snow.

17

It’s good to hear users’ experiences! How often do you have to rotate them to maintain that longevity?

18

Rotating every 5,000 to 7,500 miles is essential for any tire, especially in winter conditions. It helps with even wear.

19

While all-season tires can be versatile, don’t forget that winter tires perform better in harsh conditions. Sometimes, it’s worth the trade-off!

20

True, but I like the convenience of all-season tires for mild winter days! Any thoughts on that?